Rex,
Obviously, its a long email to respond...
You are making quite a few assumptions that are not correct. I did not imply that this should not be done in a group nor that everything should be done in a single vote - obviously, that's impractical.
I am not sure I understand the logic of not compiling all the comments first - we have done that as a first step for all the standards and I hope we continue to follow that process.
Finally, just putting all the comments on a spreadsheet is a non trivial issue - my opinion is that it will be easier to have all comments at one place - clearly, you can track everything since they will be related and may have been discussed before. You can easily track issues that were past the approval - the date column should help you with it. And you can filter the column to see the open issues. If you want to create a separate spreadsheet, please do so.
I am happy to discuss - I was not aware that you were discussing it in the SC nor recollect being mentioned in the last TC meeting. As I mentioned in my email, the spreadsheet would be a starting point for the discussions.
Sukumar