OASIS Member Discuss

 View Only

FW: Nonresponsiveness to Charter IPR Comments

  • 1.  FW: Nonresponsiveness to Charter IPR Comments

    Posted 11-20-2008 17:20
    Since I did the kick-off of the current discussion (but not its tangent into
    Telco RAND preferences), I thought I would bring it to this list for
    archival purposes and further recollection. 
    
    I have seen a number of interesting comments, on-list and off-list.  
    
    One question was whether I was objecting to a particular chartering or was
    this a general observation.
    
    1. It is a general observation.  I have seen the formulaic response "RAND is
    a valid OASIS IPR mode" in more than one instance (possibly in one of its RF
    variations too).  
    
    2. It was observing a recurrence of the formula that triggered my reaction,
    but I was not reacting in any way with regard to the chartering of that
    particular TC and its choice of IPR.  I really was questioning the
    non-responsive or dissembling nature of the formulaic response.
    
    I have further observations after seeing some reactions and on-/off-list
    discussion, but I shall mull on them a bit longer.
    
     - Dennis