Hi Tony, You're right that the group for the dialog is unnecessary. On the other hand I'm not sure if we have to duplicate exactly the same attributes in <group> and <trans-unit> elements. What I wanted to point out was that we might consider use the attributes from one <trans-unit> element (with a special attribute - e.g. for-group) as the attributes describing the whole group. Then we could remove the duplicated attributes from <group> and leave them just in the <trans-unit> element. Defaults then possibly could be used for <trans-unit>. It was just an idea and I understood we were approaching release candidate of the next version of XLIFF so there is no time for large structure changes discussions. Cheers, Mirek