emergency-comment

 View Only
  • 1.  EDXL-SitRep Review Comments

    Posted 12-20-2011 11:50
    Comments by line number for EDXL-SitRep Committee Specification Draft 01 / Public Review Draft 01 :

    114 - Should line reference Reference ManagementReportingSummary rather than Summaries.
    287 and 290 - Graphics identify ResponseResources as the report type. Elsewhere this report type is identified as ResponseResourcesTotals. Recommend updating title here of clarifying in introductory text.
    290 - Should Figure 2 “BranchDivision” be “BranchDivisionGroup”. Reference ResourceTotal under (BranchDivisionGroup and Resource) in Table 2.4.
    432 - IncidentLocation shows 1..1 in Table 2.3 but Figure 2 lists 0..* for same element.
    432 - DisasterInformation shows 0..* in Table 2.3 but Figure 2 lists 0..1 for same element.
    434 - ResourceTotal shows 0..* in Table 2.4 but Figure 2 lists 1..* for same element.
    436 - Should SummaryCount be changed to 0..11? Reference line 754 Usage statement.
    582 - Synonym of "Hey You" in comment does not seem relevant to PreparedBy.
    666 - ResourceTotal Element is identified as optional and 0..*, however in Figure 2 it is shown in bold and listed as 1..*.
    809 - Last Statement under Definition and items in () under Comments appear to be editorial notes to the authors including references to program and individual names. Recommend removing or clarifying questions as statements.
    844 - Clarify EmergencyResponseIssuesUsage as 0.._ after Optional for consistency with approach throughout document.


  • 2.  EDXL-SitRep Review - Editorial Comments

    Posted 12-20-2011 11:56
    Editorial comments by line number for EDXL-SitRep Committee Specification Draft 01 / Public Review Draft 01 :
    - Remove extra “e” from footer text. Calls out siterep rather than sitrep:
    edxl-siterep-v1.0-csprd01
    -291 is EM intended to be Element Reference Model? Call it ERM for consistency.
    361 - Remove "-" on Sit-Rep Report Type so it is SitRep
    421 - CasualtyAndIllnessSummary column 2 states "...to summarize provide information", remove provide.
    434 - Under OrganizationAndAssignments there is a typo for PersonName, currently shown as PesronName.
    464 - Remove "e" from the end of FieldObservation Report Type.
    856 - Typo on yet, remove extra "e"