OASIS ebXML Messaging Services TC

 View Only

[ebxml-msg] Issue 41: Acknowledgment/RefToMessageId element

  • 1.  [ebxml-msg] Issue 41: Acknowledgment/RefToMessageId element

    Posted 02-12-2002 18:07
    This issue points to a fundamental and inconsistent change in the 2.0
    specification when compared with the 1.0 version.  We have previously agreed
    and documented in numerous locations that ebMS signals referencing a
    particular incoming message must be sent in a message that uses the
    MessageHeader/RefToMessageId element appropriately.
    
    David has suggested this addition (which was not discussed by the group since
    I rejoined) supports bundling acknowledgements.  What makes acknowledgements
    special in this regard?  What about errors, responses to multiple message
    status requests, et cetera?
    
    I recommend we remove this element, especially because it is required and
    would normally just duplicate the value appearing in
    MessageHeader/RefToMessageId.
    
    thanx,
        doug