OASIS ebXML Messaging Services TC

 View Only

[ebxml-msg] Minutes October 15

  • 1.  [ebxml-msg] Minutes October 15

    Posted 10-16-2001 12:03
    Team
    
    ____________________________________________________________________________
    _________________________
    DO NOT FORGET - NEXT MEETING IS VOTING - non attendance without notice may
    affect your voting rights.
    ============================================================================
    =========================
    
    
    The minutes of Monday October 15 tele conference are on our web site at:-
    
    http://www.oasis-open.org/committees/ebxml-msg/minutes/TeleConference_10_15_
    2001.doc
    
    If you are not on the attendance list or I have your name wrong I am sorry
    but please tell me so that we have an accurate record.
    
    In line - not formatted.
    
    ----------------->
    
    Conference Call	10/15/01	Minutes
    
    Hosted by Sun (Chris Ferris)
    
    David Burdett
    Arvola Chan
    Sanjay Cherian
    Colleen Evans
    Chris Ferris
    David Fischer
    Ian Jones
    Brad Lund
    Bob Miller
    Dale Moberg
    Bruce Pedretti
    David Smiley
    Jeff (Turpin) (sp?) - Please confirm/correct
    Dan Weinreb
    Pete Wenzel
    Prasad Yendluri
    
    
    Agenda Items
    1. Roll Call - see above
    
    2. Conference call Schedule - all calls 10:00 Pacific/1:00 Eastern Monday
    October 22 - Hosted by Colleen Evans - Sonic Software - Voting
    October 29 - Hosted by Dale Moberg - Cyclone
    November 5 - Hosted by David Smiley - Mercator - Voting
    .
    3. Version 1.1 specification editing -
    3.1. Everyone seamed reasonably happy about the re-organization of the
    messaging specification.
    3.2. Discussion on the continued need for the delivery receipt resolved to a
    proposal to be posted to formally request its removal via a vote on the next
    call.
    3.3. The need for and use of multiple signatures in the same message was
    discussed along with methods for not invalidating the earlier signatures.
    The current suggestion is to exclude all elements with an Actor of Next from
    the required transform.  - Chris will post something to the list for people
    to consider.
    3.4. TraceHeader List - re-word the description to clarify function and use.
    3.5. Discussion on the Ack requested ( 1or 2 intermediate or "to" point) and
    the retry interval.  If both an intermediate and "to" ack's are requested do
    we need 2 retry intervals if only one to which ack does it apply?  No final
    decision but consensus moved toward only allowing the "from" to specify 1
    type but intermediates to add the other if they wished.  Anyone allowing
    both would need to define how they handled it as it is out side the scope of
    the specification.
    3.6. Delivery failure notifications may be signed if there is a concern of
    "man in the middle" security attacks.
    3.7. Discussion on Sync reply mode if HTTP is the underlying transport it
    may be possible to send a sync reply response without the business
    acknowledgment.  This may require extra clarification as the solution must
    be non transport specific and may need to detail the possible conditions as
    it is very likely that a "circuit" may be broken at some point while waiting
    for a business level response if we support many second transactions.  The
    failure could be at any point in the network for any reason and rises with
    the number of networks/distance involved.
    
    4. Arvola will issue a list of topics/issues to discuss AND RESOLVE on next
    weeks call later this week - please be prepared.
    
    5. Next face to Face - Chris Ferris and David Burdett will investigate a
    video conference link to allow people to attend a location on either coast
    as members are equally split over location.
    
    Next call October 22 @ 10:00 Pacific, 1:00 Eastern
    
    Ian Jones
    Chair OASIS ebXML Messaging Services TC 
    
    Tel: +44 (0)29 2072 4063
    Fax: +44 (0)29 2072 4137  
    Email: ian.c.jones@bt.com