Greetings! For our meeting today I have captured from emails to the discussion list an informal list of errors in ODF 1.3 Committee Specification. Hope everyone is at the start of a great week! Patrick -- Patrick Durusau
patrick@durusau.net Technical Advisory Board, OASIS (TAB) Editor, OpenDocument Format TC (OASIS), Project Editor ISO/IEC 26300 Co-Editor, ISO/IEC 13250-1, 13250-5 (Topic Maps) Another Word For It (blog):
http://tm.durusau.net Homepage:
http://www.durusau.net Twitter: patrickDurusau Informal summary of errors in odf-1.3-committee-specification -
patrick@durusau.net 27-Jan-2020 Part 2 (Regina Henschel reporting,
https://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/office/email/archives/202001/msg00009.html ) In part 2, section 4.16.9: The text lists the value PGP, but that is not contained in the generated text in the gray box. In part 2, section 4.16.14.2: The text has version "1.2", but the generated text in the gray box has "1.3" Response by Francis Cave,
https://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/office/email/archives/202001/msg00010.html *********************** Part 3 (Alfred Hellstern
https://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/office/email/archives/202001/msg00006.html ) Per
https://issues.oasis-open.org/browse/OFFICE-3868 , references to RFC4288 are to be replaced with references to RFC6838. Appendix C still contains a reference to RFC4288 Also, [MIMETYPES] is found as a reference in both the normative and non-normative sections Relating to
https://issues.oasis-open.org/browse/OFFICE-3695: The number:fraction element did exist in 1.2, but is listed in Appendix G under New Elements (in some earlier drafts it was listed in both sections) meta:creator-initials
https://issues.oasis-open.org/browse/OFFICE-3776 is listed in Appendix G on the same line as dr3d:scene, should have a line break in front of it. Also, this is listed under Changed Elements, but didn t exist in 1.2, so shouldn t it be listed under New Elements? Per
https://issues.oasis-open.org/browse/OFFICE-3857 , We re introducing style:scale-to-X and style:scale-to-Y. The JIRA issue mentions Update: <style:page-layout-properties>, style:scale-to and style:scale-to-page sections should be updated, too, with the new style:scale-to-X and style:scale-to-Y attributes. This results in these changes Adds this attribute to the attribute list of <style:page-layout-properties> 17.2 in 20.352 (ODF 1.2 = 20.344) < style:scale-to>, changes: If this attribute and style:scale-to-pages are absent, a document is not scaled. To: If style:scale-to, style:scale-to-pages 20.353, style:scale-to-X 20.354 and style:scale-to-Y 20.355 attributes are absent, a document is not scaled In 20.353 (ODF 1.2 = 20.345) <style:scale-to-page>, changes: If this attribute and style:scale-to are absent, a document is not scaled To: If style:scale-to-pages, style:scale-to 20.352, style:scale-to-X 20.354 and style:scale-to-Y 20.355 attributes are absent, a document is not scaled. Should these changes to 20.352 and 20.353 not separately be tracked by an entry in Appendix G: Changes from 1.2? Just like the changes for 3923 are listed twice? office:process-content (deleted)
https://issues.oasis-open.org/browse/OFFICE-4034 Is listed twice in the appendix, once under Changed Attributes and once under Removed elements, attributes and values 17.15 <style:table-properties> The <style:table-properties> element specifies formatting properties for tables. The <style:table-properties> element is usable within the following elements: <style:default-style> 16.4 and <style:style> 16.2. The <style:table-properties> element has the following attributes: fo:background-color 20.182, fo:break-after 20.184, fo:break-before 20.185, fo:keep-with-next 20.201, fo:margin 20.205, fo:margin-bottom 20.206, fo:margin-left 20.207, fo:margin-right 20.208, fo:margin-top 20.209, style:may-break-between-rows 20.319, style:page-number 20.328, style:rel-width 20.340, style:shadow 20.359, style:width 20.399, style:writing-mode 20.404, table:align 20.414, table:border-model 20.415, table:display 20.416 and table:tab-color Error: Reference source not found. The <style:table-properties> element has the following child element: <style:background-image> 17.3. Bookmark reference not being resolved. Appendix G has this: style:condition 19.472 of <style-map> 16.3 Office-3282 3282 should be 3882 (the hyperlink does go to the correct JIRA issue 3882) Same for table:condition table:condition 19.600 Office-3882 table:condition 19.600 of <table:content-evaluation> 9.4.5 Office-3282 3282 should be 3882 (the hyperlink does go to the correct JIRA issue 3882) table:content-evaluation should be table:content-validation Is the second line actually needed since they both point to 19.600? style:page-number 20.328 from
https://issues.oasis-open.org/browse/OFFICE-3923 lists this twice: The style:page-number attribute is usable with the following elements: <style:paragraph-properties> 17.6 and <style:table-properties> 17.15. The style:page-number attribute is usable with the following elements: <style:paragraph-properties> 17.6 and <style:table-properties> 17.15.
https://issues.oasis-open.org/browse/OFFICE-3945 For text:anchor-type, the first proposed change doesn t seem to have been implemented Change first paragraph to: The text:anchor-type attribute specifies how a drawing shape is bound to a text document. The anchor position is the point at which a drawing shape is bound to a text document. For
https://issues.oasis-open.org/browse/OFFICE-3931 presentation:display-date-number 20.236 Office-3931 should be presentation:display-page-number 20.236 Office-3931 chart:regression-type 20.50 Office-3958, Office-3959 for
https://issues.oasis-open.org/browse/OFFICE-3958 and
https://issues.oasis-open.org/browse/OFFICE-3959 this attribute already existed in 1.2, but is listed in the New Attributes section, should be in the Changed Attributes section. number:exponent-interval 19.347 Office-1828 per
https://issues.oasis-open.org/browse/OFFICE-1828 is a new attribute, but is listed under the Changed Attributes. ***************** Francis Cave responds (
https://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/office/email/archives/202001/msg00014.html ) with additional corrections: OFFICE-3868: I agree with both your points. In Appendix C the reference to RFC 4288 needs updating to refer to RFC 6838, and the [MIMETYPES] entry in 1.4 should be removed. Also, I notice in passing that the column widths of the tables in Appendix C need to be adjusted so that the filename extensions in the second column don t break over two lines. OFFICE-3695: I agree. The entry should be moved to the next list (elements that have changed). OFFICE-3776: I agree. The formatting of the list of changed elements needs tidying up: blank lines need to be removed from the list and a meta:creator-initials should be on its own line. OFFICE-3776: I agree. The changes to <style:update-page-layout-properties> (17.2) should be listed in Appendix G under elements that have changed. The changes to attributes style:scale-to (20.352) and style:scale-to-pages (20.353) should be listed in Appendix G under attributes that have changed. I notice in passing the following minor formatting issues: In 17.1 there is a blank bulleted list item, which should be deleted. In 20.352 there is a double space after If at the beginning of the second paragraph. Double spaces should be reduced to one space in the following places where they occur mid-sentence (I ve ignored double spaces between sentences and some other less odious occurrences): Table 3, row 2, column 2, between from and elements 2.2.1, D.1, between conform and to . Also, for consistency, remove blank line above C) on same page. 2.2.1, D.3, between value and has 5.3.6, second paragraph, between 5.3.1 and element . 5.4.1, first paragraph, between or and text 16.2, ninth paragraph, between parent and styles . 19.15.1, list item chart:area , third paragraph, between the and order . 19.15.1, list item chart:stock , second paragraph, between <chart:stock-gain-marker> and 11.20 . 19.107, list item matrix , between values and (<j> . 19.142, between attributes and of 19.211, second paragraph, between secondary and circle . 19.218.2, list item linear , between linear: and defines . 19.373, between <text:expression>, and <text:user-field-decl> . Table 15, heading, between Table and 15 . 19.472, list following fourth paragraph, item numberValue , between [xmlschema-2] and decimal . 19.472, final paragraph, between by and Table 16 . 19.600, second Note, between 9.4.5 and element . 19.856, between attribute and 19.857 . There is a full-stop missing after 19.857 . 20.47, first paragraph, between the and chart:regression-moving-type . 20.47, second paragraph, second sentence, between Let and formula. 20.122, list item true , between draw:fill-color and 20.119 . 20.230, second paragraph, between overflow and text . 20.349, list item distribute-space , between a (which should be an ) and amount . 20.360, first paragraph, between content and already . 20.405, list item false , between paragraph and whenever . 20.405, list item true , between paragraph and whenever . 20.418, first paragraph, between shape and is . Other nits: General: The style Text Body used to have 1.4 mm above and below the paragraph, but has none in the CS. I think that the style properties need to be checked. 4.3.1, third paragraph, remove open double quote at end (this was in ODF 1.2. 4.3.2.12, change a IRI to an IRI . 7.4.1, list item User variables , first paragraph, remove space at start of paragraph. Table 10, first row, column 4, change a ellipse to an ellipse . Table 10, several rows, column 4, change a implied to an implied . Regina Henschel reporting in part 3: Office-3662 - chart:interpolation -
https://issues.oasis-open.org/browse/OFFICE-3662 Regina's email:
https://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/office/email/archives/202001/msg00016.html ****************** Part 4 (Regina Henschel reporting) Office-3667 -
https://issues.oasis-open.org/browse/OFFICE-3667 Regina's email:
https://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/office/email/archives/202001/msg00012.html Office-3766 -
https://issues.oasis-open.org/browse/OFFICE-3766 Regina's email:
https://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/office/email/archives/202001/msg00015.html Attachment: signature.asc Description: OpenPGP digital signature