OASIS ebXML Messaging Services TC

Re: [ebxml-msg] Re: Comments on the 1.09 about ConversationId

  • 1.  Re: [ebxml-msg] Re: Comments on the 1.09 about ConversationId

    Posted 12-03-2001 13:01
    David, thanks for your comments, it brings us back to some of the "what's
    the size of this hole?" issues we previously had with a few security issues.
    
    In general, Marty is coming closest to saying "what's wrong with having the
    application wait for an Acknowledgment message before sending another
    message?"  This seems to be a core issue: The Message Order module in MSH is
    purely an efficiency mechanism.  It doesn't add support for message ordering
    to the infrastructure, it only makes multiple outstanding (un-acknowledged)
    messages possible.  How important is that efficiency?
    
    Even if it is very important, we have a number of issues raised in this and
    the related "... MessageOrder" thread indicating this module isn't fully
    baked.  I'd like to add an additional issue: A conversation seems to last
    throughout the lifetime of a business process instance (one run through the
    BPSS "script").  However, only a few points (if any) in that business
    process are going to require explicit re-ordering of outstanding messages.
    The scope of the sequence we've defined remains far too large.
    
    thanx,
        doug