UBL Naming and Design Rules SC

RE: [ubl-ndrsc] Minutes from 5 March NDR Call

  • 1.  RE: [ubl-ndrsc] Minutes from 5 March NDR Call

    Posted 03-06-2003 09:41
    I did actually send regrets but the mail I sent to Mark bounced back for
    some reason.
    
    Matt
    
    > -----Original Message-----
    > From: CRAWFORD, Mark [mailto:MCRAWFORD@lmi.org]
    > Sent: Wednesday, March 05, 2003 7:12 PM
    > To: UBL Design Rules (E-mail)
    > Subject: [ubl-ndrsc] Minutes from 5 March NDR Call
    > 
    > 
    > The NDR SC met by phone on Wednesday, 5 March 2003 from 16:30-17:58
    GMT.
    > Please use the following dial-in information:
    > 
    > 1.  Roll Call and Welcome from the chair (Mark), assignment of
    co-chair to
    > take minutes.
    > 
    > Mavis Cournane	Present (left at x:30)
    > Eduardo Gutentag	Regrets
    > Jessica Glace		Present
    > Michael Grimley	Regrets
    > Paul Thorpe		Regrets
    > Kris Ketels		Regrets
    > Bill Burcham		Regrets
    > Gunther Stuhec	Present (at x:12)
    > Matt Gertner		AWOL
    > Dan Vint		AWOL
    > Fabrice Desr�		AWOL
    > Lisa Seaburg		Present (at x:15)
    > Ann Hendry		Present
    > Arofan Gregory	Present
    > Sue Probert		Regrets
    > Jim Wilson 		Regrets
    > Eve Maler 		Present
    > Jon Bosak		Present
    > Mark Crawford	Present
    > Marion Royal		Present at x:25
    > 
    > at x:10 we did not have quorum and proceeded informally
    > 
    > 2.  Acceptance of minutes from previous meeting - deferred due to lack
    of
    > quorum.
    > 
    > 3.  Adoption of agenda/schedule planning.  Adopted
    > 
    > 4. Review priorities and assignment of work items (Mavis/Lisa/Mark)
    > 
    > Mavis helping Gunter with common core components document.  Have
    chunked
    > this document out to 9 people with due back to Mavis on 3/10.  We have
    > gotten a lot of comments back from Garrett indicating that there is a
    > divergence between Op70 and CCTS version 1.9.  Some general discussion
    on
    > this issue.  Ann read one comment and the sense of the group was that
    we
    > have the issue covered, but we may not have it well explained in the
    > release package.
    > 
    > Gunter asked the question regarding representation terms (primary and
    > secondary)  and core component types.  There appears to be some
    confusion
    > and Gunter needs to make more clear the association and identification
    of
    > primary and secondary representation terms and CCTs.  Gunter will put
    in
    > additional documentation.
    > 
    > 5. Review NDR release schedule (Mark)
    > 
    > Mark has received only the input from Bill.  Others still
    > 
    > Local v Global			Waiting on report from Jim
    > ModNamVer			Bill has submitted
    > Core Components		Gunter and Mavis have paper in progress.
    Due next
    > week
    > Embedded Documentation	Group has made decision.  XHTML is
    decision.
    > Mavis to write narrative to support rule.
    > 
    > There was some discussion surrounding Gunter's embedded documentation
    > paper and how to post.  Gunter will ensure that XHTML option is
    included
    > and that the decision of the NDR to use XHTML is included as an
    editorial
    > comment.  Mavis will review, edit, and post.
    > 
    > 6. Review Code list output (Lisa)
    > 
    > Lisa has sent material to list.  Has seen Eve's email posted today,
    but
    > has not followed through with it.  Lisa will pursue.  Eve thinks that
    the
    > UN/ECE is moving in our direction and is close to what we need but we
    > still need to work with them to really adhere to what we are doing and
    to
    > come to agreement on what attributes (see Gunter's paper) are needed
    for
    > well known code lists as opposed to what attributes are required for
    > lesser known code lists.  Lisa and Arofan need to look at what Eve has
    > sent out and compare with CCTS 1.9.  Eve and Lisa and Arofan will have
    a
    > call on Monday to discuss and will have updated paper by mid next week
    to
    > share with UN/ECE and ATG2.
    > 
    > 7. Updates on status of Local vs. Global (Jim)
    > 
    > Jim has submitted report that only one comment was received.  Mark
    stated
    > that procedurally there does not appear to be support for reversing
    the
    > decision.  Jon raised an issue that we did not give sufficient time
    for
    > the discussion and he can't believe that people don't have an opinion.
    > Eve stated that she does have some thoughts, but they are not to
    reverse
    > the decision, rather to take advantage of opportunities to improve the
    > process for defining the names and improving the pearl script.  Eve
    will
    > look at the paper in more detail.  We will extend the comment period
    until
    > Monday the 17th.  Lisa will send announcement to UBL listserve
    indicating
    > that comment period is extended.
    > 
    > 8. Containership (Arofan)
    > 
    > Arofan has three problems with the existing release 1) there may be
    some
    > processing concerns with some built-in inefficiencies in how the
    library
    > is structured 2) if not neatly encapsulated, then it is difficult to
    > understand and there may be binding issues 3) with the containership
    as it
    > stands, if we try and extend using the context mechanism, we have
    > insufficient containers to add header type of field and so would have
    to
    > add after all of the line items.  Eve says that we discussed 3 in our
    > original containership discussions, but we have said that if we
    normalize,
    > if we use real semantic basis, then adding to the end does not cause a
    > problem since they are related to the parent.  But the actual
    performance
    > issue may mean that we need to revisit.  Eve agrees that we never
    reached
    > formal agreement on containership and that in October we felt that we
    were
    > in general agreement with the LC approach, but we reserved final
    judgment
    > until after we looked at the Op70 release.  Arofan does not think
    these
    > containers are a semantic function, but a design function.  Arofan has
    two
    > proposals: 1) Do we artificially insert a header and body container
    (not
    > proposing a summary container) and 2) when we have lists of like
    things,
    > for performance reasons and encapsulation reasons do we have a
    container
    > that wraps around them - i.e. list containers.  Arofan feels these are
    the
    > points where LC normalization breaks down.  Eve thinks there may be
    > semantic issues.  Eve
    > might support more containers if done smartly.  Mark asked if we can
    > define clear rules that would ensure consistent LC approach.  Arofan
    feels
    > it can.  Mark asked if Arofan would update paper.  Arofan proposed
    > alternative in which he would write specific rules and supporting
    > narrative.  Mark asked Marion if he thought we should have discussion
    with
    > LC.  Marion said we should do on listserve.  Arofan does not think it
    is
    > LC issue.  Eve suggested that Arofan update paper, NDR review and
    discuss
    > on next weeks call, and then if we agree with Arofan's proposal we
    then
    > enter into discussions with LC to determine if they have any pushback.
    > Arofan to have paper out by end of week and we will discuss on next
    weeks
    > call.
    > 
    > 9. Polymorphism Resolution
    > 
    > Eve is not sure that what we are talking about under polymorphism is
    > really inheritance.  Mark wants to know how to discuss in NDR
    document.
    > Matt is supposed to be providing some words that describes this for
    > inclusion in the ModNamVer paper.  Mark query Matt and Bill to see if
    this
    > has happened.
    > 
    > 10. Administrative Matters
    > 
    > Portal Update - Lisa to ping Mavis to get portal up to date.
    > Membership Status - two prospective members.  Mark to raise issue on
    > chairs list:  two people are they voting members.
    > 
    > 11. Other business.  None.
    > 
    > Next call scheduled for 12 March.
    >
    http://www.timeanddate.com/worldclock/fixedtime.html?day=12&month=3&year
    =2
    > 003&hour=16&min=30&sec=0&p1=0
    > 
    > 
    > We adjourned at Y:28.
    > 
    > ----------------------------------
    > 
    > Mark
    > Mark Crawford
    > Research Fellow - LMI XML Lead
    > W3C Advisory Committee, OASIS, RosettaNet Representative
    > Vice Chair - OASIS UBL TC & Chair Naming and Design Rules Subcommittee
    > Chair - UN/CEFACT XML Syntax Working Group
    > Editor - UN/CEFACT Core Components
    > ______
    > Logistics Management Institute
    > 2000 Corporate Ridge, McLean, VA 22102-7805
    > (703) 917-7177   Fax (703) 917-7481
    > Wireless (703) 655-4810
    > mcrawford@lmi.org
    > http://www.lmi.org
    > "Opportunity is what you make of it"
    > 
    > 
    > ----------------------------------------------------------------
    > To subscribe or unsubscribe from this elist use the subscription
    > manager: <http://lists.oasis-open.org/ob/adm.pl>
    
    ----------------------------------------------------------------
    To subscribe or unsubscribe from this elist use the subscription
    manager: <http://lists.oasis-open.org/ob/adm.pl>