OASIS Open Document Format for Office Applications (OpenDocument) TC

Greetings!

More comments on the responses to the editorial notes on the graphics 
material:

draw:start-glue-point

We currently say:

> The |draw:start-glue-point| attribute identifies the glue point in a 
> shape where a connector starts by its number. See 9.3.16. Glue point 
> numbers are defined by the |draw:id| attributes of the glue point 
> elements |

***************************************
>
> Christian also posted a note on:
>
> anim:audio-level
>
> We say:
>
>> The |anim:audio-level| attribute specifies the volume during 
>> playback. Its value is a number in the range 0 (inaudible) to 1 (the 
>> system volume).
>>
> My comment and the response:
>>
>> Ed. Note System volume is undefined and that in the schema the 
>> datatype is double.
>>
>> CL: System volume means that you can't define the sound to be louder 
>> than what the user set as the loudest volume on his system. So '1' is 
>> the maximum volume allowed on that system and 0.5 would be half of that.
>>
> OK, so would:
>
> "The |anim:audio-level| attribute specifies the volume level during 
> playback. Its value is a number in the range 0 (inaudible) to 1 (the 
> maximum system volume)."
>
> do the trick?
>
> Hope everyone is having a great day!
>
> Patrick

I think that it would be more clear with:

"The |anim:audio-level| attribute specifies the volume level during 
playback. Its value is a number in the range 0 (inaudible) to 1 (the 
current system volume)."

As a non-native English speaker, "maximum system volume" sounds very 
loud (i.e. if I have my PC connected with my home theater, they'll form 
a very loud system). Also, the text proposed my Patrick may bring me 
translation problems if I need to translate ODF 1.2 to Brazilian 
Portuguese, as I did with ODF 1.0 (BTW, I hope I really need to 
translate 1.2).

Best,

Jomar

Jomar,


Jomar Silva wrote:
> ***************************************
>>
>> Christian also posted a note on:
>>
>> anim:audio-level
>>
>> We say:
>>
>>> The |anim:audio-level| attribute specifies the volume during 
>>> playback. Its value is a number in the range 0 (inaudible) to 1 (the 
>>> system volume).
>>>
>> My comment and the response:
>>>
>>> Ed. Note System volume is undefined and that in the schema the 
>>> datatype is double.
>>>
>>> CL: System volume means that you can't define the sound to be louder 
>>> than what the user set as the loudest volume on his system. So '1' 
>>> is the maximum volume allowed on that system and 0.5 would be half 
>>> of that.
>>>
>> OK, so would:
>>
>> "The |anim:audio-level| attribute specifies the volume level during 
>> playback. Its value is a number in the range 0 (inaudible) to 1 (the 
>> maximum system volume)."
>>
>> do the trick?
>>
>> Hope everyone is having a great day!
>>
>> Patrick
>
> I think that it would be more clear with:
>
> "The |anim:audio-level| attribute specifies the volume level during 
> playback. Its value is a number in the range 0 (inaudible) to 1 (the 
> current system volume)."
>
> As a non-native English speaker, "maximum system volume" sounds very 
> loud (i.e. if I have my PC connected with my home theater, they'll 
> form a very loud system). Also, the text proposed my Patrick may bring 
> me translation problems if I need to translate ODF 1.2 to Brazilian 
> Portuguese, as I did with ODF 1.0 (BTW, I hope I really need to 
> translate 1.2).
>
Yes, but your suggestion of "the range 0 (inaudible) to 1 (the current 
system volume)." would mean that if I already have my "system" volume 
set to 0 that there would be no sound at all, ever.

My wording may not be the best so feel free to suggest other language 
but I think what we are trying to say is there is a range of volume that 
runs from 0 (inaudible) to 1 (which I called the maximum, feel free to 
suggest other language) but at the other end of the range from inaudible.

The real difficulty being that we never define "current system volume" 
and I am not really sure how we would do so.

Hope you are looking forward to a great weekend!

Patrick

> Best,
>
> Jomar
>

-- 
Patrick Durusau
patrick@durusau.net
Chair, V1 - US TAG to JTC 1/SC 34
Convener, JTC 1/SC 34/WG 3 (Topic Maps)
Editor, OpenDocument Format TC (OASIS), Project Editor ISO/IEC 26300
Co-Editor, ISO/IEC 13250-1, 13250-5 (Topic Maps)

Patrick Durusau 

Rob,

Good idea.

Jomar, would the following work?:

******
"The |anim:audio-level| attribute specifies the volume level during 
playback. Its value is a number in the range 0 (muted) to 1 (maximum)."

Note: The actual volume level experienced by a user is application, 
operating system and hardware dependent.
******

Hope you are looking forward to a great weekend!

Patrick

robert_weir@us.ibm.com wrote:
> Patrick Durusau 

It sounds very good to me.

Best,


Jomar



                                                

					
                                                    

        
                                                
				
                                                

                                                    
                                                        
                                                        Original Message
                                                
                                                Original Message-----
From: Patrick Durusau