OASIS ebXML Messaging Services TC

RE: [ebxml-msg] Minutes 12/03/01 - Voting Meeting

  • 1.  RE: [ebxml-msg] Minutes 12/03/01 - Voting Meeting

    Posted 12-03-2001 16:43
    In my opinion:
    
    For ping, pong, StatusRequest and StatusResponse the spec says to Soap fault
    with a code of "MustUnderstand" (section 8, line 1790) but this doesn't seem
    to be very meaningful. These type of messages will not be specified as
    "supported" in a CPA and there is nothing in the ebXML message that any
    ebXML MSH could not parse since the "unsupported" part will be on the action
    value and not a new element. Given that a MSH has to explicitly look at the
    action to decide if it supports this, I think a error list of "NotSupported"
    makes for much better MSH error handling verses a soap fault. Especially, if
    the Ping/StatusRequest requests an async response.
    
    I think we should still have an errorcode of NotSupported used for these
    types of MSH messages that are not required to be implemented by an MSH.
    
    Cliff
    
    >