OASIS Web Services Interactive Applications TC

[wsia] Current Journalism: XML.COM article on Web Services

  • 1.  [wsia] Current Journalism: XML.COM article on Web Services

    Posted 03-21-2002 13:39
    Hi Folks,
    
    This article came up on the xml-dev list, so I read it and I am 
    passing it along.
    
    http://www.xml.com/pub/a/2002/03/20/endpoints.html
    
    I think that Rich's suggestions in the Embedded Use-Case for 
    wsia-specific terminology address some of the issues in the 
    typing/coupling choices we need to make, or for which we need to 
    provide. However, we have cases that need the entire range of strong 
    to weakly typed and tightly to loosely coupled AND static synchronous 
    (short, specific, immediate single-packet) to dynamic (long, 
    intermittent, streaming, changeable-stateful) messaging exchange 
    patterns. THAT's a lot to chew on. I suppose the question that is 
    nibbling at me is, do we need to chew on all of it at once?
    
    We have broken our use-cases down (somewhat) into levels of 
    complexity. Should we start by working on the simpler LCD spec 
    requirements first and start writing spec on that while continuing to 
    explore the more complex issues? What concerns me is that we may get 
    rather further along in writing spec than the underlying structure 
    can support at present. I have a feeling that harvesting some 
    low-hanging fruit soon might influence the on-going debates about 
    HTTP, SOAP, etc. I have had the notion in my head for a while that we 
    might want to look at more than a single messaging transport 
    protocol, and see if such an arrangement would be amenable to 
    synchronization and integration with HTTP, SOAP, et al, and still be 
    deliverable in protocol/device independence.
    
    Maybe I just like to worry, eh?
    
    Ciao,
    Rex
    --