csaf-comment

 View Only
Expand all | Collapse all

CSD04 6.1.66 / 9.1.18: converted documents can change their year folder (Requirement 11)

  • 1.  CSD04 6.1.66 / 9.1.18: converted documents can change their year folder (Requirement 11)

    Posted 8 days ago

    Dear CSAF TC,

    I checked how the new initial_release_date rule in 9.1.18 (test 6.1.66, #1691) affects published documents: 40,882 CSAF 2.0 documents from 50 publishers, taken from the CIRCL vulnerability-lookup dumps of 4 October 2026 (excluding Red Hat and SUSE).

    The converter would replace initial_release_date in 12,765 of them, almost all from Cisco (2,850) and MSRC (9,808). In 9,658 MSRC documents revision 1 is dated later than initial_release_date, and almost all of these already fail test 6.2.5. For them the converter moves initial_release_date later, in 2,041 documents into a later year (in 1,436 by more than 365 days).

    One example:
    https://msrc.microsoft.com/csaf/vex/2023/msrc_cve-2023-0225.json
    initial_release_date is 2023-04-01; the only revision ("1", "Information published.") is dated 2024-10-15. After conversion, initial_release_date is 2024-10-15, so Requirement 11 places the CSAF 2.1 document in folder 2024, while the CSAF 2.0 document and its self reference use 2023.

    During the parallel distribution described in 7.4, the same document would then sit in two different year folders. Is that intended? If so, would it help if the converter's warning also mentioned the year change?

    Happy to share the per-document list and the counting script.

    Best regards,



    ------------------------------
    Christian Bucher
    Public View
    ------------------------------


  • 2.  RE: CSD04 6.1.66 / 9.1.18: converted documents can change their year folder (Requirement 11)

    Posted 7 days ago

    Dear Mr. Bucher,

    thank you for commenting on CSAF 2.1 CSD04. We have opened an issue to track your comment: https://github.com/oasis-tcs/csaf/issues/1724

    Kind regards,

    Thomas Schmidt



    ------------------------------
    Thomas Schmidt
    Subject Matter Expert
    Federal Office for Information Security (BSI) Germany
    ------------------------------