OASIS Open Document Format for Office Applications (OpenDocument) TC

 View Only

General comments to proposal for SORT function, OFFICE-4157

  • 1.  General comments to proposal for SORT function, OFFICE-4157

    Posted 06-24-2024 11:03
      |   view attached
    Hi all,

    in case you do not get the attachments, please drop me a note and I'll
    sent them to you directly.

    Here some larger comments including links besides the comments in the
    attached file.

    (A)
    The proposal mentions "dynamic array". A concept of "dynamic array" is
    missing in ODF.

    "dynamic array" is missing in LibreOffice, only in first generating of
    the result array, the actual needed place is used.
    https://bugs.documentfoundation.org/show_bug.cgi?id=161642

    Excel uses flag fDynamic in CT_DynamicArrayProperties, 2.4.87
    dynamicArrayProperties in [MS-XLSX] Extensions to the Office Open XML
    SpreadsheetML File Format.
    Excel provides the spilled range operator # to be placed directly after
    the reference to the first cell to address the whole column.
    https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/office/spilled-range-operator-3dd5899f-bca2-4b9d-a172-3eae9ac22efd
    Excel uses #SPILL! error, if the to be filled area is not empty.


    (B)
    database headers are not considered.
    Excel: UI: "Format as table" and there checkbox "My table has headers".
    Feature request

    https://feedbackportal.microsoft.com/feedback/idea/2a55004c-1db0-ee11-92bd-6045bd7fe601
    Excel can address parts of the table by using [#All], [#Headers]
    or [#Data] (maybe more?).

    LO: UI: Data > Define Range > Options: "Contains column labels".

    ODF: Attribute table:contains-header (19.604) of element
    <table:database-range> (9.4.15)

    Kind regards,
    Regina</table:database-range>

    Attachment(s)