Time: 4:30 PM EST
Zoom Link:
http://tinyurl.com/48n4yrzsMeeting ID: 850 9753 8468
Minutes for 24 July 2025 TC Meeting
I. Roll Call & Minutes
Voting members
Bill Parducci (Co-Chair)
Steven Legg
Cyril Dangerville
Voting Members: 3 of 4 (75% - quorum)
Approve Minutes for 26 June 2025 TC meeting
https://groups.oasis-open.org/discussion/minutes-26-june-tc-meeting Approved unanimously
II. Administrivia
Discord
Unofficial conversations are now happening in Discord to help facilitate communication
in more real time manner than email.
discord.gg/MJpMsMAF
Timeline
Current goal is to have at least Working Draft agreed upon for feedback within August.
III. Issues
Short Identifiers
There was general consensus to proceed with Short Identifiers in the following manner:
* "SID" agreed upon as short name identifier.
* "SIDCollection" agreed upon as collection of SIDs
* SID will used throughout the specification, with an introduction.
Steven has posted examples online:
https://github.com/oasis-tcs/xacml-spec/blob/xacml-4.0-core-spec/xacml-v4.0-csd01.md There was a conversation about how to handle the non-unique nature of SIDs. The general
consensus is that duplicate SIDs will be rejected. This will happen procedurally at the
evaluation level, but likely has larger operational parameters (e.g. tooling ensuring
uniqueness, PAP validation, etc.) Steven will generate some additional text around SIDs
in the document to highlight Best Practice considerations in addition to explicit
enforcements/limitations.
ACAL
There was general consensus to formally name this version of the specification ACAL. As
the specification Core progresses work will begin on the language specific versions:
* The XML representation will remain XACML and be XACML, v4.0
* The JSON representation will be JACAL, v 4.0
* The YAML representation will be YACAL, v4.0
ACTION ITEM:
Bill to request the ACAL start document from TC Admin
The next meeting will be held in 4 weeks.
meeting adjourned.