Data Provenance (DPS) TC

 View Only
  • 1.  Executive Brief + Slide Deck – Drafts for Review

    Posted 08-27-2025 17:46

    Hi Everyone,

    Per yesterday's TC meeting, please find attached the draft Executive Brief PDF and Slide Deck. We'd love to start receiving feedback on both.

    As discussed in the meeting, we've allocated two weeks for review, so please provide your feedback by Wednesday, 10 September.

    Feel free to reach out with any questions.

    Regards,
    Jane


    --

    Jane Harnad

    Director of Marketing & Events

    OASIS Open

       
    +1 703-508-3373
    jane.harnad@oasis-open.org
    www.oasis-open.org/events



  • 2.  RE: Executive Brief + Slide Deck – Drafts for Review

    Posted 08-27-2025 18:32

    Jane and TC Members,

    Feedback on the Executive Brief DPS for your consideration:

    • The document switches between "OASIS Data Provenance (DPS)" and "OASIS Data Provenance Standards (DPS)". Suggest choosing one and using it consistently throughout. 

    • Key concepts, including trust, interoperability, transparency, AI deployment without guesswork, and procurement benefits, are reiterated multiple times throughout the sections. For example: "AI Deployment Without the Guesswork" appears both as a headline and again in narrative text. Suggest condensing these ideas into a single, clear, and strong section to avoid redundancy. Additionally, repeated slogans/headlines like "AI Deployment Without the Guesswork" could be used once, in a highlight box or graphic, instead of being scattered throughout the content.

    • Many sentences are longer than necessary. For example: "Adopting the DPS isn't just a compliance task-it's a declaration of intent. It signals an organization's readiness to lead in a future defined by transparent, trustworthy, and ethical data practices." We can shorten this to: "Adopting DPS is more than compliance-it signals readiness to lead in a transparent and ethical data future." Similar opportunities exist throughout, and I recommend a general tightening pass, which should also shorten the document overall.

    • Numbering is inconsistent (some sections use "01, 02, 03", others use bullet points or narrative flow). We might want to streamline this for ease of visual reference.

    • Headings are not always aligned in tone. Some are declarative ("TRUSTED DATA PROVENANCE STANDARDS ARE ESSENTIAL") and others are descriptive ("Business Impact & Benefits"). Suggest unifying into a consistent style.

    • "Business Impact & Benefits," "Expected Outcomes," and "Key Recommendations" all repeat similar benefits (compliance, trust, procurement efficiency). These could be merged into a shorter, more focused section.

    • The "Call to Action" and "Commit to Actionable Change" overlap; these could be streamlined into a single, strong closing section, as suggested by Andy.

    • Acronyms are frequently used without being defined (e.g., AI, RFP). Should we define terms for non-technical readers?

     

    Feedback on Executive Brief Slides for your consideration: 

    • Document sometimes says "OASIS Data Provenance Standards (DPS)" and elsewhere just "OASIS Data Provenance" or "Data Provenance Standards." Recommend always using the full form OASIS Data Provenance Standards (DPS) at first mention on each major section, then DPS thereafter.

    • Multiple slides repeat the same benefit statements in different forms: "AI deployment without guesswork" appears twice (Expected Outcomes & Business Impact). "Trusted data = reduced risk, higher incomes, lower costs" is reiterated in both Business Impact and Closing Thoughts. Procurement certainty / compliance / efficiency are mentioned across at least 3 slides. I suggest consolidating into a single strong "Benefits & Outcomes" slide with 4–5 crisp points.

    • Some slides are text-heavy and read more like a whitepaper than slides (e.g., "Operational Benefits" and "Leadership & Implementation"). For executive slides, less is more so I think we should use 3–4 bullet points max per slide. If we have a video to accompany the Executive Brief, we can use the supporting text for speaker delivery.

    • We need to tell the story consistently in all of the DPS materials (The Challenge (why this matters), The Solution: DPS (what it is), Benefits & Outcomes (group all compliance, AI trust, procurement together), Leadership Actions (steps: pilot → collect metadata → visualize → align → scale), Call to Action / Closing (ecosystem engagement, next steps)). Doing so would cut redundancy and make the deck more compelling.

    • Several slides are lists that could be strengthened as visuals (e.g., "Recommendations for Leaders" could be presented as a roadmap diagram, or "Expected Outcomes" could be transformed into a 4-block visual (AI Confidence / Efficiency / Trust / Compliance). "Interoperable Standards" could be a framework diagram showing taxonomy, lineage, policy, restrictions.

    • Nitpicks: Slide "WHY TRUSTED DATA PROVENANCE MATTERS" has a typo: "itegrity" → should be integrity. Some capitalization inconsistencies: e.g., "Cross-industry collaboration" vs "CROSS-INDUSTRY COLLABORATION." Suggest aligning to a single style (title case recommended for slide decks).

    • The last two slides ("Closing Thoughts" and "Commit & Connect") overlap. We should merge into a single action-oriented final slide with: Key value statement (trusted data = lower risk, higher performance), Clear call to action (pilot → scale → share → connect), and Contact info. 


    Thank you,

    Kristina







  • 3.  RE: Executive Brief + Slide Deck – Drafts for Review

    Posted 08-28-2025 11:20

    Jane, this looks great. I put my comments in the file. I would also like to get a powerpoint copy as soon as possible so I can put the OSI presentation together from this base.

     

    Lisa Bobbitt (lbobbitt)

    Principal Engineer, Privacy

    Cisco  

     






  • 4.  RE: Executive Brief + Slide Deck – Drafts for Review

    Posted 08-28-2025 11:46
    Sounds good. Can you send me the OSI presentation info. So we can promote on our end? Jane


    On Thu, Aug 28, 2025, 11:22 AM Lisa Bobbitt via OASIS <Mail@mail.groups.oasis-open.org> wrote:
    Jane, this looks great. I put my comments in the file. I would also like to get a powerpoint copy as soon as possible so I can put the OSI... -posted to the "OASIS Data Provenance Standard Technical Committee" community

    Data Provenance (DPS) TC

    Post New Message
    Re: Executive Brief + Slide Deck – Drafts for Review
    Reply to Group Reply to Sender via Email
    Aug 28, 2025 11:20 AM
    Lisa Bobbitt

    Jane, this looks great. I put my comments in the file. I would also like to get a powerpoint copy as soon as possible so I can put the OSI presentation together from this base.

     

    Lisa Bobbitt (lbobbitt)

    Principal Engineer, Privacy

    Cisco  

     



      Reply to Group via Email   Reply to Sender via Email   View Thread   Recommend   Forward  




     
    You are receiving this notification because you followed the 'Executive Brief + Slide Deck – Drafts for Review' message thread. If you do not wish to follow this, please click here.

    Update your email preferences to choose the types of email you receive

    Unsubscribe from all participation emails




    Original Message:
    Sent: 8/28/2025 11:20:00 AM
    From: Lisa Bobbitt
    Subject: RE: Executive Brief + Slide Deck – Drafts for Review

    Jane, this looks great. I put my comments in the file. I would also like to get a powerpoint copy as soon as possible so I can put the OSI presentation together from this base.

     

    Lisa Bobbitt (lbobbitt)

    Principal Engineer, Privacy

    Cisco  

     





  • 5.  RE: Executive Brief + Slide Deck – Drafts for Review

    Posted 08-28-2025 13:44

    Here is the linked info https://www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn%3Ali%3Aactivity%3A7366131817831194626/?midToken=AQHShn0lw49Icw&midSig=167iBkc5HRErU1&trk=eml-email_notification_single_mentioned_you_in_this_01-hero_notification_cta-0-1ep~cta&trkEmail=eml-email_notification_single_mentioned_you_in_this_01-hero_notification_cta-0-1ep~cta-null-e0odk~mesum33u~i8-null-null&eid=e0odk-mesum33u-i8

     

    Event/Publication Name:
    Open Source Initiative - Deep Dive: Data Governance
    Event/Publication Date: October 1 - 3, 2025
    Role: Presenting at VIRTUAL CONFERENCE (PRERECORDED PRESENTATION):
    Topic:  How Data Provenance Powers Trustworthy AI

    "Today's AI models depend on an invisible supply chain: the data they're trained and fine-tuned on. But who's responsible for documenting, disclosing, and governing that lineage? Without standardized automated ways to capture and communicate data provenance, responsible AI and regulatory compliance remain wishful thinking and the risk of harm when using this data rises . This talk charts the journey from corporate innovation to open standard, specifically how the Data & Trust Alliance developed the first cross-industry data provenance specification, and how it's now being shepherded through the OASIS Open standards process to ensure open governance, interoperability, and adoption across sectors. We'll walk through:

    ● Why provenance is essential for trustworthy AI

    ● How governance, signaling, and stewardship intersect in real-world enterprise settings

    ● The role of open standards in translating principles into practice

    ● Lessons learned from cross-industry collaboration

    ● What's next: implementation guides, tools and enterprise adoption

     

    This is a talk for practitioners, policy thinkers, and engineers who want more than frameworks, and are looking for tools, standards, and field-tested insights that can scale with the complexity of AI systems."

     

    Lisa Bobbitt (lbobbitt)

    Principal Engineer, Privacy

    Cisco  

     






  • 6.  RE: Executive Brief + Slide Deck – Drafts for Review

    Posted 08-28-2025 14:00

    https://www.linkedin.com/company/open-source-initiative-osi-/posts/

     

     

    Lisa Bobbitt (lbobbitt)

    Principal Engineer, Privacy

    Cisco